Enrolment is the first thing here that writes: template containers through the
gpfile listener and counter records through RPMB. It refuses to run unless both
--sfs-writable and --rpmb-write are given, and it refuses to call SAVE_DATA if
the sample count did not reach zero, because a partial template is worse than
none.
The sequence is stock's: cancel, reset-lockout, authenticate, cancel,
reset-lockout, PRE_ENROLL, authenticate, cancel, ENROLL, the sample loop,
POST_ENROLL, SAVE_DATA with bit 30 set. AUTHENTICATE is what arms the capture
session, which is why it appears in an enrolment at all.
Enrolment takes one sample per PRESS: touch on the rising edge, release on the
falling one, nothing in between. Stock's entire enrolment trace contains no
image-ready event, and feeding every held frame gives the algorithm
near-duplicate images from a single press.
Two things named honestly. The ENROLL payload's u32 at +69 was recorded here as
a "timeout"; the trustlet reports it back as the GROUP ID, and filling a
mislabelled field with a plausible number is the entire provenance of gid 60.
It is the gid now, so an enrolment can choose its own group.
And --group-path exposes the namespace key the trustlet hashes into the group's
directory name. It defaults to Android's, which is where this device's existing
store lives and how that template is readable. But SAVE_DATA rewrites the
group's index container, and an index QTEE later fails to verify takes every
template listed in it -- so enrolling into a DIFFERENT namespace is complete
isolation from a store we did not write.
Arms a scan session and drives the frame loop: capture, decide finger from the
calibrated floor, report the touch edges, classify the verdict.
It needs no writes of any kind -- no SAVE_DATA, no RPMB write, no SFS write --
so it runs safely against an existing template with the store read-only. That
is what makes it the right thing to try before enrolment rather than after.
Verified armed on the phone: the template loads, the floor calibrates, and
AUTHENTICATE returns rc=0, which also proves the gid agrees with the one
SET_ACTIVE_GROUP used (a mismatch answers -200). With no finger present the
loop correctly reports nothing: no touch edge, no event, no terminal frame.
The fid field is poisoned before every REPORT_EVENT, because a zero-initialised
buffer cannot distinguish "the matcher never ran" from "the matcher ran and
rejected" -- the failure path writes zero there too.
The tally reports terminal frames as the denominator and presses separately,
so a run cannot be read as having rejections it did not have.
The whole storage path now works from the daemon. On the phone, against the
real store:
listener 0x7000 sb=516096 -> result=0 REGISTERED
listener 0x2000 sb=25600 -> result=0 REGISTERED
SET_ACTIVE_GROUP gid=60 path='/data/vendor_de/0/fpdata'
gpfile READ .../1lPrxAL0vXRvWPeDkW2c off=4096 len=252114
...
CMD 0x2005 -> result=0 rc=1
templates loaded: 1
QTEE read a 252114-byte enrolled template through our gpfile listener, verified
it, and loaded it. Since QTEE unlinks any container whose keyed integrity tag
fails, a load is proof the framing is right -- the read/write offset split, the
container chunking, and the RPMB anti-rollback read that has to succeed before
QTEE will trust any of it.
RPMB is served too: SECURITY PROTOCOL IN/OUT against the RPMB well-known LUN,
retrying the unit attention the LUN raises once after a reset. Writes are
refused unless asked for, because they advance a counter that cannot be moved
back, and key programming is refused unconditionally.
The store was served READ-ONLY throughout, which is the point. A listener that
serves bytes at the wrong offset does not merely fail: QTEE deletes the
container it cannot verify, and that is an enrolled fingerprint gone. Read-only
makes a wrong build harmless, so it is the default and writing is opt-in.
Two ordering facts, both of which produce -2 with no storage read at all --
indistinguishable from a broken listener:
* a template reload needs the device init chain to have run FIRST, because
that chain allocates the per-slot array the reload writes through;
* SET_ACTIVE_GROUP's second field is a NAMESPACE path, not a filesystem one
and not the gid again. The trustlet hashes it into the group's directory
name, so it has to match what the store was written under.
Also: a positive rc is not an error code. ENUMERATE returns the template count
there, and running that through the error table printed "unknown" for a good
answer.
The finger-free path is complete. On the phone, from a cold start:
client env -> loader -> trustlet -> config -> sensor rail -> init chain
calibrating the idle floor (5 samples)
idle 1/5: rc=-11 metric=133
...
idle floor = 133, finger threshold = 266
133 is the number the journal records for this sensor, so the port reproduces
the reference measurement rather than merely producing one.
Two things had to be right at once, and the first attempt had neither.
The memory region: CAPTURE_IMAGE reads an output-buffer pointer out of
payload+0x00, and QTEE only patches an address there if the location is named
in embeddedBufOffsets and the region handed over in an object slot. The
instrumented dump shows it working -- payload+0x00 came back holding
0x088db98000 -- which is what made the remaining failure legible instead of
mysterious.
And two fields inside the capture payload that an all-zero request leaves
unset: a frame count at +0x0c and a branch selector at +0x10. Selector 0
returns metric 0. Sending zeros gets -201 with the region correctly attached,
which reads exactly like a broken region and is not one. They are named
constants now, with the note that the metric is PER FRAME so a threshold
calibrated at one frame count means nothing at another.
The flags word at payload+0x18 stays past the declared length of 0x14 on
purpose: the trustlet range-checks that length to exactly 0x14 and reads the
flags anyway.
--verbose keeps the region and reqOut dumps, which is what turned this from
guesswork into reading.
On the phone, end to end from the daemon:
lookupTA('focal64') -> result=23 (nothing to unload)
trustlet loaded from /lib/firmware/focal64.mbn, distName='fingerprint'
config /lib/firmware/fingerprintd.json: 349 bytes
CMD 0x100d -> result=0 rc=0 (Success)
CMD 0x2005 -> result=0 rc=0 (Success)
The config is the one fp6fpcfg.py --daemon generates, so the reduction of nine
hand-edited ffcfg files to one generator is confirmed against the trustlet
rather than only against the files it replaced.
A stale instance is unloaded before loading, which is what stops a crashed
experiment costing a reboot; result=23 is the clean-slate answer.
The request envelope moves into Fingerprintd:Ta with the rest of the layouts:
command id at +0, declared length at +4, payload at +0x10, and on the way back
the trustlet's own rc at +8 and the capture metric at +0x0c. Both are HEADER
fields ahead of the payload -- the metric has been miscalled "payload+12" in
this project's notes, and every recorded finger number depends on reading it
where it actually is.
ENUMERATE answering rc=0 is correct here and not a regression: no group is
active and no storage listeners are registered yet, so there are no templates
to count.
Fingerprintd:Ta is the second core module: request payloads, response fields,
the error table, and the rule that decides what a frame meant. Payload building
and response reading only -- no TEE, no transport.
Very little of this is guessable, so each constant carries where it came from.
Three were found only because QTEE recorded a fault naming the instruction that
read them:
* the event context's scan-slot count at +712, which do_enroll branches on to
skip the entire slot loop -- an all-zero payload logged "groups->,
results->" and read exactly like a gate failing deep in the trustlet, when
it was zero iterations;
* CAPTURE_IMAGE's flags at payload+0x18, without which preprocessing, the
classifier and the enrol grouper never run at all, whatever is on the
sensor;
* SYNC_STATISTICS, whose absence leaves g_statistics NULL so the first enrol
frame that gets far enough takes a data abort and every later command
answers -90.
The verdict rule gets the most attention because it was mislabelled three times
before the comparison producing it was read. A frame is one of three things and
only the third is a verdict: the poison intact means the matcher never ran,
rc=-11 means not identified yet with attempts remaining, and only rc=0 carries
a match or a rejection. The poison exists because a zero-initialised buffer
cannot tell a released finger from a rejected one.
The tests are in two halves that cannot prop each other up. Explicit wire
conditions pin the classifier; three recorded runs pin the counting policy,
which is what actually went wrong. In the stock-budget run 31 of 48 frames
answered "not identified yet" and every frame that carried an image matched --
counting those 31 as attempts turns 8-for-8 into 8-of-39 and reads as a flaky
sensor. The wrong-finger control pins zero false accepts.
Fixtures are verdict-line excerpts, not the 40 KB transcripts, which are thick
with the device's SFS container names the test has no use for.
Verified by mutation: classifying -11 as a rejection, dropping SYNC_STATISTICS
from the init chain, and forgetting the +0x10 response payload offset each fail
the suite.
